and with equal success. His first play, Ivanov, opened in Moscow on November 19, 1887. In January 1889 it was staged in Petersburg, where it was greeted with enthusiasm and much discussed in the newspapers and literary journals. The production later toured the provinces.
But, precisely because of its originality, Chekhov’s work met with opposition from the established critics of the time. For decades literary criticism had been dominated by political ideologists, who judged literary works according to their social “message,” their usefulness to the common cause. The writer was seen first of all as a pointer of the way, a leader in the struggle for social justice; his works were expected to be “true to life” and to carry a clear moral value. Faced with stories like “Anyuta” or “Easter Night,” what were these critics to say? What were they to think of a writer whose first precept was the “absence of lengthy verbiage of a political-social-economic nature”? Chekhov’s “impressionism” was seen as a form of art for art’s sake, a denial of the writer’s social role, and a threat to the doctrine of realism, and he was attacked for deviating from the canons of useful art.
In fact, just as Chekhov created a new kind of story, he also created a new image of the writer: the writer as detached observer, sober, restrained, modest, a craftsman shaping the material of prose under the demands of authenticity and precision, avoiding ideological excesses, the temptations of moral judgment, and the vainglory of great ideas. That is how Chekhov himself has most often been seen, and certainly it was in part what he wanted to be. He often joked about his ideological shortcomings. “I still lack a political, religious and philosophical world view,” he wrote to Grigorovich on October 9, 1888. “I change it every month—and so I’ll have to limit myself to descriptions of how my heroes love, marry, give birth, die, and how they speak.” He considered that the writer’s job, and thought it was enough. On October 27, 1888, he wrote to Alexei Suvorin:
The artist must pass judgment only on what he understands; his range is as limited as that of any other specialist—that’s what I keep repeating and insisting upon. Anyone who says the artist’s field is all answers and no questions has never done any writing or had any dealings with imagery. The artist observes, selects, guesses and synthesizes … You are right to demand that an author take conscious stock of what he is doing, but you are confusing two concepts: answering the questions and formulating them correctly. Only the latter is required of an author.
The leading critic of the time, the populist Nikolai Mikhailovsky, said that those who admired Chekhov admired him precisely for the “indifference and impassibility” with which he applied his excellent artistic apparatus to a swallow or a suicide, a fly or an elephant, tears or water—“a revelation they call ‘the rehabilitation of reality’ or ‘pantheism.’ All in nature … is equally worthy of artistic treatment, all can give equal artistic pleasure, and one must avoid selection according to a general idea or principle.” Mikhailovsky considered this a waste of Chekhov’s genuine talent. And Tolstoy, for all his admiration, was of a somewhat similar opinion. In August 1895, after Chekhov’s first visit to his estate, he noted in his diary: “He is very gifted, must have a good heart, but up to now he has no definite point of view on things.” The place Chekhov gave to contingency in his choice of themes and arrangement of details, the lack of any general idea to unify the whole, was considered his great originality or his great defect as an artist.
Chekhov privately defended himself against the attacks of his critics in a letter written on October 4, 1888, to Alexei Pleshcheev, literary editor of the Northern Herald:
The people I am afraid of are the ones who look for tendentiousness between the lines and are determined to see me as either liberal or conservative. I am neither liberal nor conservative, nor gradualist, nor monk, nor indifferentist. I would like to be a free artist and nothing else, and I regret God has not given me strength to be one. I hate lies and violence in all their forms, and consistory secretaries are just as odious to me as Notovich and Gradovsky [two unscrupulous left-wing journalists]. Pharisaism, dullwittedness and tyranny reign not only in merchants’ homes and police stations. I see them in science, in literature, among
Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 1 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 2 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 3 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 4 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 5 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 6 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 7 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 8 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 9 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 10 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 11 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 12 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 13 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 14 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 15 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 16 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 17 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 18 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 19 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 20 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 21 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 22 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 23 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 24 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 25 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 26 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 27 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 28 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 29 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 30 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 31 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 32 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 33 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 34 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 35 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 36 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 37 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 38 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 39 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 40 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 41 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 42 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 43 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 44 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 45 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 46 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 47 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 48 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 49 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 50 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 51 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 52 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 53 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 54 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 55 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 56 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 57 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 58 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 59 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 60 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 61 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 62 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 63 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 64 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 65 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 66 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 67 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 68 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 69 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 70 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 71 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 72 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 73 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 74 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 75 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 76 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 77 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 78 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 79 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 80 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 81 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 82 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 83 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 84 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 85 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 86 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 87 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 88 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 89 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 90 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 91 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 92 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 93 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 94 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 95 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 96 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 97 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 98 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 99 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 100 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 101 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 102 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 103 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 104 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 105 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 106 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 107 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 108 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 109 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 110 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 111 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 112 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 113 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 114 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 115 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 116 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 117 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 118 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 119 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 120 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 121 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 122 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 123 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 124 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 125 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 126 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 127 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 128 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 129 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 130 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 131 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 132 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 133 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 134 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 135 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 136 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 137 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 138 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 139 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 140 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 141 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 142 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 143 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 144 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 145 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 146 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 147 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 148 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 149 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 150 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 151 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 152 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 153 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 154 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 155 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 156 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 157 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 158 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 159 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 160 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 161 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 162 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 163 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 164 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 165 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 166 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 167 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 168 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 169 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 170 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 171 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 172 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 173 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 174 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 175 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 176 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 177 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 178 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 179 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 180 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 181 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 182 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 183 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 184 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 185 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 186 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 187 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 188 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 189 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 190 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 191 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 192 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 193 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 194 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 195 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 196 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 197 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 198 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 199 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 200 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 201 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 202 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 203 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 204 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 205 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 206 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 207 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 208 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 209 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 210 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 211 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 212 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 213 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 214 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 215 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 216 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 217 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 218 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 219 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 220 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 221 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 222 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 223 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 224 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 225 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 226 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 227 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 228 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 229 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 230 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 231 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 232 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 233 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 234 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 235 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 236 Selected Stories of Anton Chekov - By Anton Chekhov - Page 237